Discover the best protein cookies that taste like dessert. Vegan, gluten-free, and indulgent options from Lenny & Larry's, Buff Bake, and more.
Protein cookies are the perfect marriage of dessert and nutrition. These soft-baked, indulgent treats deliver serious protein without sacrificing taste. Whether you’re craving chocolate chip, birthday cake, or peanut butter, there’s a protein cookie that satisfies while fueling your body.
Lenny & Larry’s Complete Cookie Chocolate Chip revolutionized the protein cookie category with 16 grams of plant-based protein from pea and brown rice. It’s large enough to share (or not!) and genuinely tastes like a bakery-fresh cookie.
Buff Bake Birthday Cake Protein Cookie brings the party with 15g protein in an almond butter-based cookie. Their flavor innovation includes Birthday Cake, Snickerdoodle, and White Chocolate Peanut Butter.
Dessert-Like Experience:
Versatility:
Nutritional Benefits:
Lenny & Larry’s leads this category with complete plant-based protein from pea and brown rice. Their formula proves vegan cookies can be incredibly delicious.
Benefits:
Browse all vegan protein snacks and plant-based options.
Buff Bake cookies use gluten-free oats and almond butter, making them safe for celiac disease and gluten sensitivity.
Features:
Explore more gluten-free protein snacks.
Both Lenny & Larry’s and Buff Bake use nut butters as their base:
Advantages:
| Cookie | Protein | Calories | Sugar | Fat | Fiber | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lenny & Larry’s Complete | 16g | 320 | 14g | 10g | 10g | $18.99/box |
| Buff Bake Birthday Cake | 15g | 280 | 11g | 10g | 5g | $19.99/box |
Protein Content:
Serving Size:
Sugar:
Room Temperature:
Traveling:
Freezing:
The original protein cookie company since 1993. Known for:
Almond butter specialists offering:
vs Protein Bars:
vs Regular Cookies:
vs Protein Brownies:
Browse protein bars, protein chips, or jerky.
Lenny & Larry’s is 100% vegan with plant-based protein. Perfect for those avoiding animal products.
Buff Bake uses certified gluten-free ingredients. Safe for celiac disease.
Many protein cookies carry these certifications. Check individual product labels.
Common allergens in protein cookies:
Always verify ingredients for specific allergies.
High Protein:
Fiber Content:
Healthy Fats:
Lenny & Larry’s:
Buff Bake:
Both offer excellent value compared to protein bars ($2-3 each).
Major Retailers:
Online Direct:
Quality protein cookies like Lenny & Larry’s and Buff Bake offer real nutrition - high protein, fiber, and better ingredients than regular cookies. They’re healthier alternatives but should still be consumed mindfully.
Yes! They’re great for active kids, especially in lunch boxes. The protein helps them stay full and focused. Just watch serving sizes (one cookie is often 2 servings).
Both options work well due to high protein (increases satiety) and fiber (promotes fullness). The key is portion control - stick to one serving.
Modern protein cookies taste remarkably similar to regular cookies. Lenny & Larry’s and Buff Bake have perfected their formulas over years.
Or browse by diet:
Return to High Protein Snacks Directory | Compare all protein snack categories
The MunkPack Protein Cookie is a premium protein snack made with high-quality ingredients. With 18g …
The Quest Protein Cookie is a premium protein snack made with high-quality ingredients. With 15g of …
Buff Bake Birthday Cake Protein Cookie brings the celebration to your protein cookie experience. …
Lenny & Larry’s The Complete Cookie is the original vegan protein cookie that started the …
Transform your mornings with Legendary Foods Tasty Pastry - the keto-friendly protein snack that …